I have spent the last few years testing various household maintenance products to see what actually keeps appliances running like new. In my experience, both Affresh Dishwasher Cleaner and Finish Dishwasher Cleaner stand out as top-tier options for tackling hard water buildup and grease. I ran multiple cycles with each cleaner in my own stubborn dishwasher to determine which one delivers the best results for your home.
Affresh Dishwasher Cleaner Detailed Review
Keeping a dishwasher clean requires targeting the hidden zones where grime loves to accumulate. I started testing the Affresh Dishwasher Cleaner because my machine began emitting a damp, musty odor. These tablets are formulated to power away odor-causing residues that settle deep inside the pump, tub, and recirculating hoses. A major benefit of this product is that it can be used with or without dishes during a normal cycle. It is also EPA Safer Choice Certified, which gives me peace of mind regarding the chemicals washing down my drain. Appliance manufacturers like Whirlpool and Maytag officially recommend this brand for regular maintenance.
- Powers away smells caused by bacteria, limescale, and mineral buildup in hidden parts.
- Safe for dual use so you can clean your machine while running a full load of dishes.
- EPA Safer Choice Certified and safe for septic systems.
- No messy powders or liquids due to the easy-to-use tablet format.
- Trusted by appliance experts with official recommendations from Whirlpool, Maytag, and KitchenAid.
Pros
- Highly convenient since you can wash dishes and clean the machine simultaneously.
- No strong chemical smells left behind after the cycle completes.
- Easy to store without risking leaks or spills.
- Septic-safe formula is gentler on home plumbing systems.
Cons
- Tablets may not dissolve completely if the wash water temperature is too low.
- Does not tackle heavy, baked-on grease buildup as quickly as liquid alternatives.
Best for: Homeowners looking for a convenient, eco-friendly way to maintain their dishwasher during normal dishwashing cycles.
Expert Opinion: The dual-use capability of Affresh makes it the most convenient option for busy households who want to keep their appliance smelling fresh without running empty cycles.
Finish Dishwasher Cleaner Detailed Review
When grease and heavy mineral scale build up, a liquid cleaner is often required for a deep purge. I tested the Finish Dishwasher Cleaner Liquid to see if it could tackle the stubborn white film coating my spray arms. This dual-action liquid deep cleans hidden grease and breaks down limescale in the hardest-to-reach mechanical parts. The brand claims this formula offers 5x more cleaning performance compared to standard cleaning tablets. You must run this bottle in an empty hot cycle, which allows the active ingredients to sanitize the entire interior. Utilizing this treatment every three months helps improve dishwasher performance and prevents future drainage issues.
- Deep cleans inner parts including the filter, spray arms, and drainage pipes.
- 5x more cleaning performance than typical dishwasher cleaner tablets.
- Fights odors at the source by removing the grease that causes bad smells.
- Improves overall performance of your machine for cleaner dishes.
- Liquid formula designed for empty, high-temperature wash cycles.
Pros
- Exceptional at cutting through heavy grease and thick limescale.
- Cleans the entire machine thoroughly in a single run.
- Simple peel-off wax seal design makes application touch-free.
Cons
- Requires running an empty dishwasher cycle, which consumes extra water and energy.
- Has a strong chemical fragrance that lingers in the kitchen for a few hours.
Best for: Those dealing with severe hard water scaling, clogged spray arms, or heavy grease accumulation in their machine.
Expert Opinion: Finish Liquid is the superior choice for restoring heavily neglected dishwashers because its liquid acid formula dissolves thick mineral blockages far better than dry tablets.
Affresh vs Finish Dishwasher Cleaner: Key Differences That Matter
Performance Comparison
Dry tablets and liquid solutions work differently inside a hot washing machine. Affresh relies on a slow-dissolving tablet that works alongside your regular detergent or alone. In my testing, it did a fantastic job of removing musty smells and light mineral film. Finish Liquid uses a dual-layer liquid formula that releases when the wax plug melts during a hot cycle. This intense liquid wash is far more effective at stripping away thick, greasy residue from the filter and clearing clogged spray arm holes.
Price and Value Analysis
When looking at the overall cost, these two options present different long-term values. Affresh packages usually contain six tablets, providing a six-month supply if used monthly. The price per use is relatively low, and you save utility costs by running it with a load of dishes. Finish typically comes in a multi-pack of liquid bottles meant to be used once every three months. While the individual bottles cost more per clean, you use them less frequently throughout the year.
Form Factor and Application
The physical design of these products dictates how you use them. Affresh comes as solid, individually wrapped tablets that are completely mess-free. You simply drop a tablet into the bottom of the tub or the detergent tray. Finish is packaged in a plastic bottle with a wax-sealed cap. You must remove a sticker and place the bottle upside down in the silverware basket. The build of the Finish bottle relies on your dishwasher hitting a high enough temperature to melt the wax plug, which can sometimes fail if your water heater is set too low.
User Experience Differences
Using these two cleaners feels entirely different. With Affresh, the process is incredibly simple because you do not have to wait for an empty machine. I threw it in with a dirty load of plates and went about my day. Finish requires a completely empty dishwasher run on the hottest setting. The post-cycle smell also differs. Affresh leaves a very subtle, clean scent, while Finish fills the kitchen with a strong, chemical fragrance that takes some time to dissipate.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Affresh Dishwasher Cleaner if:
– You want to clean your machine without wasting water on empty cycles.
– You prefer an eco-friendly product with an EPA Safer Choice certification.
– Your main issue is musty odors rather than heavy grease buildup.
– You want a quick, monthly maintenance routine that takes zero extra effort.
Choose Finish Dishwasher Cleaner if:
– Your dishwasher has visible white limescale crust or clogged spray arms.
– You have not cleaned your machine in over six months and need a deep purge.
– You want to dissolve greasy buildup hidden deep inside the drainage pipes.
– Your dishes are coming out with a gritty residue or spots.
For most households, keeping both of these products in the cleaning cabinet yields the best results. I prefer using Affresh on a monthly basis to keep odors away and maintain basic cleanliness without wasting water. When my machine starts struggling with hard water spots or shows signs of grease buildup after heavy cooking seasons, I deploy a bottle of Finish for a thorough, heavy-duty restoration.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How often should I use a dishwasher cleaner?
A: You should use a maintenance tablet like Affresh once a month to keep odors away. Deep cleaning liquids like Finish are designed for use every three months to strip away heavy grease and scale.
Q: Can I use Affresh with dishes in the machine?
A: Yes, Affresh is formulated to be completely safe to run with your dishes and regular detergent. This makes it highly convenient compared to liquid cleaners that require an empty machine.
Q: Which is better for hard water, affresh vs finish dishwasher cleaner?
A: In the battle of affresh vs finish dishwasher cleaner for hard water, Finish is the winner. The liquid formula contains powerful citric acid that dissolves thick limescale deposits much faster than a solid tablet.
Q: Do I need to remove the cap on the Finish bottle?
A: No, you should not remove the plastic cap. Only peel off the sticker on top of the cap to expose the wax plug, then place the bottle upside down in your plate rack or silverware basket.
Q: Is Affresh safe for septic systems?
A: Yes, Affresh is septic-safe and carries the EPA Safer Choice certification, making it a more environmentally friendly option for rural homes.
Q: Can I use dish soap as a substitute for these cleaners?
A: No, never put regular liquid dish soap into your dishwasher. It will create an uncontrollable mountain of suds that can flood your kitchen and damage the internal electronics.
Q: Which product is more cost-effective when comparing affresh vs finish dishwasher cleaner?
A: When comparing affresh vs finish dishwasher cleaner for budget-conscious users, Affresh is generally more cost-effective. It costs less per use, and because you can run it with a normal load of dishes, you save on water and electricity bills.
When you purchase a product through Amazon links on kitchinprep.com, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We may earn a commission on qualifying purchases made through our links, including those from Amazon and other partners, at no extra cost to you.
Kris S. Cary is the founder of KitchinPrep.com and a passionate kitchen enthusiast with over three years of experience in the culinary world. A graduate of the Culinary Management, A.S. program at Daytona State College in Daytona Beach, USA, Kris spent two years honing their skills and deepening their love for cooking and kitchen essentials. Specializing in kitchen baking tools, Kris is dedicated to sharing practical tips, insightful product reviews, and expert guides to help home cooks elevate their baking and cooking game. When not testing the latest kitchen gadgets, Kris is likely whipping up something delicious or dreaming up new ways to inspire culinary creativity.